Episode Twenty-Five: Poison Pen Letter

Episode Twenty-Five: Poison Pen Letter

In 1976, several Circleville, Ohio residents were receiving strange letters detailing personal information about their lives. Bus driver Mary Gillespie was accused of a supposedly non-existent affair with a school official. The writer then turned violent and carried out the murder of Mary's husband, Ron Gillispie, although police claim that he died in an accident.

In 1983, Mary was harassed along her bus route, and she later found a booby trap designed to kill her. Her own brother-in-law, Paul Freshour, was accused of the crime and indicted on circumstantial evidence.

Proclaiming his innocence, Freshour went to prison, even as he himself received letters determined to keep him there. Even though he was in solitary confinement, letters kept arriving. In May 1994, Paul was paroled, and continues to maintain his innocence.

This was the predecessor for another case involving poison pen letters. In June 2014, a family from New Jersey receives several chilling notes from an unidentified stalker calling themselves “The Watcher” after they bought the six-bedroom turn-of-the-century mansion. The letters so terrified the family that they never moved into the property, which has remained empty for the past two years.

Who sent these letters? Were they a hoax? Or something more sinister?

Some of our research

The Circleville Letters

Paul Freshour website 

The Watcher House

The Watcher house update

Episode Twenty-Six: Sumter County Does

Episode Twenty-Six: Sumter County Does

Episode Twenty-Four: June Robles

Episode Twenty-Four: June Robles